Term papers writing service


Compare contrast essay great gatsby book movie

In the film adaptation, producer Jack Clayton stays very closely to the plot and even quotes the novel verbatim but fails to capture the essence of the themes portrayed in the novel.

The text did not translate well into film; some facts are distorted, the depiction of the characters are different, the general ambience of certain settings do not match, and the movie is weighted towards the beginning of the book, with half of the movie based closely on the first two chapters of the book. In the novel, Gatsby was seen as one who is withdrawn, quiet and romantic. In the film, however, he is portrayed as one who is loud, obnoxious and openly proclaims his wealth.

Also, the movie revolves mainly around Gatsby, which makes him more of a personal character, whereas in the compare contrast essay great gatsby book movie, Gatsby is a main character but is not as prominent as he was in the film. Fitzgerald, 12 Tom was a strong, built man. However, in the film adaptation, he appears no stronger than the average man. His strength symbolizes his authority over Daisy and his dominance provided contrast against Gatsby, who was more reserved.

  • Decor of colour and class would invigorate their living area to more closely match its description in the book;
  • In that scene, Gatsby awkwardly reaches out;
  • The 1974 version of The Great Gatsby followed the novel very closely.

Film and Novel Comparison We have so large base of authors that we can prepare a unique summary of any book. How fast would you like to get it?

The Great Gatsby Book Vs. Movie Essay

We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails. Because this aspect of Tom was left out, the film is less effective in showing this. Daisy Mia Farrow was very convincing in her role as Daisy Buchanan. She appeared to be very sweet and light-hearted upon reuniting with Nick. Aside from her high voice and sarcastic acting, there is not much difference from the novel.

Myrtle In the book, Myrtle appeared to be gaudy, impulsive and arrogant. Generally, she was not well liked and was not particularly attractive. Myrtle, in the novel, contrasted Daisy; Daisy was beautiful, elegant and mannerly.

  • In the film, Gatsby does not talk a walk outside the house;
  • Gatsby's death is not describe in the novel, it is barely mentioned that they found him in the pool with blood floating about him and "...

Myrtle, in the film, was almost similar to Daisy: In the book, his mansion is described as lavish and tasteful though Gatsby himself is not tasteful, his mansion and its furnishings are. But in the film, his mansion is but a venue for parties — it is grandiose but lacks taste.

This does not adequately show the elegance and taste of their home as described in the book. Nick was very relaxed and spoke casually with Gatsby because he was unaware of his identity. Nick knew Gatsby wanted to speak to him because his butler had informed Nick of this prior to their conversation, which very formal as a result. In the film, Gatsby does not talk a walk outside the house. In the novel, they had been acquainted for only 5 years.

In the film, they dance with only the light from a candle. In the book, they dance with only the light gleaming from the hallway. This was not mentioned in the novel.

  1. I feel this was crucial to the story.
  2. The secret relationship was described in both the novel and the movie, but it was elaborated more in the movie version. To portray a more realistic interpretation of The Great Gatsby, those actors should be replaced.
  3. Even so, the film fell short of my expectations.
  4. In the book version, Nick and his friend Jordan Baker run into each other at the party, and Jordan decides to look for Gatsby. Gatsby asked Jordan Baker to suggest to Nick the tea party.
  5. I haven't even seen the host. In the novel, they had been acquainted for only 5 years.

In general, the film rendition of The Great Gatsby follows the book very closely. Even so, the film fell short of my expectations. The acting and the styles of the cast was fair but the appearances of some of the actors were unfitting. Tom was expected to be a strong, built man and Myrtle was expected to be unattractive, gaudy and clueless — she was supposed to be a pest.

  1. Many scenes of the plot differ as well, between the film and the book.
  2. He played a very important role in the story, even though he only appeared twice in the book.
  3. In the film, Gatsby does not talk a walk outside the house. This could be done just for practical reasons.
  4. But in the film, his mansion is but a venue for parties — it is grandiose but lacks taste. The two men began to talk about the war for some time and then their conversation turned to the party.
  5. A moment later [Myrtle] rushed out into the dusk, waving her hands and shouting; before he could move away from his door the business was over... This basic plot is the same in the movie and the novel.

To portray a more realistic interpretation of The Great Gatsby, those actors should be replaced. Aside from Tom and Myrtle, the rest of the cast was decent.

The overall wardrobe was a little disappointing. I had also expected to see a wider variety of dance moves. While this is not significant, it definitely would improve the overall ambience of the film and would better engage the viewers.

The Great Gatsby

In the film, all of their furnishings are white or yellow, very bland. This contrasts the description in the book, their house was inviting and lively. Decor of colour and class would invigorate their living area to more closely match its description in the book. Many scenes of the plot differ as well, between the film and the book.

In the film, their conversation was very formal and tense. Need Help With Your Essay? I feel this was crucial to the story.

The Great Gatsby

In that scene, Gatsby awkwardly reaches out. Instead of reaching out, he should have just stared and appear to be in deep thought.

  • She appeared to be very sweet and light-hearted upon reuniting with Nick;
  • They could be omitted either for careless of the producer or just because they were not considered important facts;
  • He feels uneasy and keeps looking toward the patio and calling out Daisy's name;
  • When they met, Gatsby knew exactly who Nick was, where in the novel he did not.

Like many films based on books, the themes and much of the meaning are lost in the translation from text to film. Clayton should add new scenes to develop and reinforce the themes and feelings in the film. Even with said improvements, it is difficult to replicate all the meaning in a well written book.