Term papers writing service


The controversy of the debate about capital punishment in the case of michael curly

The controversy of the debate about capital punishment in the case of michael curly

Clayton Locket died from a heart attack after a two-hour long ordeal of agony. Joseph Wood struggled to breath for hours until the drugs administered to him finally caused him to die of suffocation. All of these men were sentenced to death for crimes they committed, yet they suffered immeasurably more than necessary due to complications regarding the drug Midazolam. Forced to switch from sodium thiopental after anti-death penalty groups coerced the drug off of the market, states began to experiment with a three drug Midazolam cocktail.

The occurrences in Ohio and Oklahoma used different compounds of the drug than Florida. Midazolam is a sedative and is intended to induce unconsciousness in the patient it is administered to. In regards to lethal injections it is intended to make the victim unconscious, while the drugs administered with it cause the victims heart to stop beating.

  1. When Midazolam is ineffective the victim is consciously subjected to the other drugs within the cocktail, feeling the drugs work on their dying body.
  2. Joseph Wood struggled to breath for hours until the drugs administered to him finally caused him to die of suffocation. Only the chief justice of Texas' Supreme Court voted against the resolution, according to several justices who were present.
  3. Their suffering amused him.
  4. Berkshire Eagle Editorial - Saturday, November 12, 2005 Dead on arrival Massachusetts has a legitimate claim to being one of the most enlightened states in the country, in part because it does not give the government the power to execute prisoners.

When Midazolam is ineffective the victim is consciously subjected to the other drugs within the cocktail, feeling the drugs work on their dying body. He was executed with the same cocktail of Midazolam used on Locket and Wood on January 15th, without the appearance of suffering.

Gross concludes, unless a chemical substitute is procured. These recents events raises a plethora of concerns and questions regarding the most controversial topic of the American judicial system. The appeals process for death row inmates is one such concern.

These potentially lesser quality legal teams then wade through the monstrosity of legal jargon and bureaucratic labyrinth that is the appeals process for victims sentenced to death. This system of state and direct appeals is out of date and ineffective. Four justices voted to stay the execution, yet five votes are necessary. Gross was not thrown out because it received sufficient votes to be considered by the Supreme Court. That number is four votes.

I, and many others, find it extremely concerning that in the United States of America it takes more votes to reconsider executing a man than to consider a case. Despite the ineffectiveness of the judicial system in this situation, measures should exist that prevent the use of drug cocktails that have been used in botched executions. Following a botched execution, certain protocol needs to exist that outlines what steps should be taken to prevent further suffering as experienced by McGuire, Locket, and Wood.

Perhaps the most interesting facet of this issue is the reason Midazolam is being used by various states. As stated earlier, anti-death penalty groups targeted various drug manufacturers, prompting them to cease the sale of sodium thiopental, a drug previously used for lethal injections. This begs the question of had anti-death penalty groups not targeted pharmaceutical companies, would McGuire, Locket, and Wood have suffered?

They might not have. As an opposer of the death penalty, this greatly concerns me.

  • If they wished Ross a slow, painful death, we would not judge them;
  • They're making something very simple very complex;
  • Boston Globe - Friday, April 29, 2005 Romney files death penalty bill Measure sets out tight restrictions By Raphael Lewis, Globe Staff Governor Mitt Romney yesterday filed a long-awaited bill to reinstate the death penalty in Massachusetts for deadly acts of terrorism, killing sprees, murders involving torture, and the killing of law enforcement authorities;
  • Byron Rushing said the bill would misdirect resources that could be used in other public safety areas;
  • Good riddance to Michael Bruce Ross;
  • With its risk of irreparable harm, it also is dreadful public policy.

It also forces humanitarian groups to consider what means should be used to achieve change in America. Huffington Post Filed Under: I want to examine issues, debates, and current events surrounding the death penalty, because after all it's a matter of life and death.