Term papers writing service


Robert latimer wont get benefits of the new policy

  1. Parked across the tidy yard is the half-ton Chevy pickup, the one he filled with deadly carbon monoxide fumes to end the life of his severely disabled 12-year-old daughter, Tracy, on Oct.
  2. He continues to do so in his demand for a pardon.
  3. It's time these barnyard ethics are put to a stop. The Significance of Charter Rights The Charter has a pervasive and controlling impact on the growth and content of the law.
  4. He also presented a journal in which Laura Latimer frequently described her daughter in positive terms.

Last Edited December 15, 2013 Robert Latimer watches in detached amusement as a kitten plays with his shoelaces. It is the day after a second jury has found him guilty of second-degree murder, and he is relaxing with half a dozen relatives on the deck in front of his modest farmhouse in Wilkie, Sask.

Search The Canadian Encyclopedia

Latimer Convicted, Again Nov97 Updates Robert Latimer watches in detached amusement as a kitten plays with his shoelaces. Parked across the tidy yard is the half-ton Chevy pickup, the one he filled with deadly carbon monoxide fumes to end the life of his severely disabled 12-year-old daughter, Tracy, on Oct. Although it is an unseasonably mild November afternoon, he makes sure his cousin Don Danbrook, a quadriplegic who travelled from British Columbia to show his support, is properly wrapped in a sleeping bag against the fall air.

Lindsay's been pretty good, but Brian's hyper.

Robert latimer wont get benefits of the new policy

It will take him a while to calm down. In a courtroom in Battleford, 35 km north of Wilkie, 12 jurors found him guilty last week of second-degree murder.

Pardoning Robert Latimer is not justified

That conviction was overturned by the Supreme Court of Canada because police, following Crown orders, had improperly questioned potential jurors about their attitudes towards mercy killing. The lawyer has applied for a special constitutional exemption from the mandatory minimum - an attempt to reduce the period before Latimer is eligible for parole - arguing that the punishment is cruel and unusual. The trial judge, Court of Queen's Bench Justice Ted Noble, will hear the sentencing arguments, and hopes to decide within 10 days.

It was clear the jury found the sentence excessive. Before considering their verdict, the jurors had asked Noble what the sentence would be, but he replied that he could not tell them. After the guilty verdict was announced in court, several jurors were clearly shocked to learn it meant a life sentence with no access to parole for at least 10 years. Some gasped and covered their mouths with their hands, and two began to cry.

The jury then made an unusual - and likely unenforceable - recommendation: While he may feel relatively isolated on his 1,280-acre canola and wheat farm, Latimer is at the centre of an emotional public debate that is addressing thorny ethical and philosophical questions about the fairness of the Canadian legal system, the value of a human life, the meaning of pain and suffering, and the morality of mercy killing.

Is Latimer a merciful father? The jury was in a dilemma because Latimer was charged with an robert latimer wont get benefits of the new policy for which there is no discretion. They are furious that the legal system would even consider leniency for Latimer. Alarmed by the perceived threat to people with disabilities, the organization mounted a national campaign after Latimer's first trial.

Latimer Case Factum 2000

Although many advocates for the disabled felt relieved after last week's guilty verdict, some believe Latimer is getting off too easily. Julian Bodner, a Saskatoon lawyer with cerebral palsy, says he should have faced an even more serious charge.

There have been a few calls and a few letters. We haven't opened them yet. Friends and family have rallied around. Von Fuchs views Tracy's death as part of a "continuum" that begins with brain-damaged infants, some so severely handicapped that doctors quietly remove life support within hours of birth. It is unfortunate, she adds, that because mercy killing has been "criminalized," Latimer felt he had to act alone, without the help of a social worker or medical expert.

Von Fuchs, and other members of the euthanasia movement, is calling for a change in attitude to mercy killing. We cannot fix everyone every time forever.

We Need Your Support

The doctor recommended the removal of the child's right thigh bone - an operation that would ease her pain, but would leave her leg hanging from her tiny, twisted body. Now they're going to start mutilating my little girl. It just seemed like something you wouldn't do to your pet.

  1. The discretion is to be exercised for the benefit of that person, not for that of others.
  2. Latimer a new trial. Justice Ted Noble then imposed a light sentence because sentencing Mr.
  3. Whether the label is mentally ill, mentally handicapped or mentally retarded, or couched in more specific, professional terminology such as Down's Syndrome, schizophrenia or Prader Willes' syndrome, the label sets the problem of discrimination in motion. The Court should appreciate that fear and decide this case in a fashion which sends a strong message that the criminal law will protect the lives of all Canadians.
  4. The judge and jury concluded that Mr. The End of Silent Acceptance?

I said to him, 'It would be better for Tracy if she died. But I wished for it for her. The wheelchair-bound teenager was a vivid reminder of Tracy - a point her mother, Rita Wolfe, and other advocates for the disabled who attended the trial intended. During a break in the trial, she challenged reporters to understand her point of view. It's time these barnyard ethics are put to a stop. Crown prosecutor Eric Neufeld called 17 witnesses in his attempt to show that Tracy experienced no more pain than many other children with disabilities.

He also presented a journal in which Laura Latimer frequently described her daughter in positive terms. Must a person like Tracy die because another person cannot bear to watch her fight?

Latimer Convicted, Again

The court heard that Tracy could take nothing stronger than regular Tylenol for her pain because other drugs interfered with her anti-seizure medication, repressed her breathing, and limited her already poor gag reflex, increasing the risk of her choking to death.

We're not asking you to change the law to allow mercy killing.

  • Justice Ted Noble then imposed a light sentence because sentencing Mr;
  • Lyons, [1987] 2 S;
  • Red hook town board meeting may 28, 2008 councilman robert latimer clarified that nothing contained in the proposal will benefit councilman latimer.

I simply ask you to find Robert Latimer not guilty. Noble's instructions to the jurors were stark. He gave them two options: And the only possible conviction is second-degree murder, he added.

The Latimer Case: The Reflections of People with Disabilities - Chronology

The lesser crime of manslaughter was not a option, he said, because Latimer clearly acted with intent. Four hours later, Latimer put out his cigarette outside the Battleford courthouse and plodded up the steps to hear the verdict.

Aging floorboards creaked as 40 or so spectators - loyal friends and relatives as well as angry advocates for the disabled - hurried into the same dome-ceilinged, oak-trimmed room. The jurors - seven women and five men - filed back into the courtroom, purposefully avoiding eye contact with Latimer, who sat, in jeans and a black nylon windbreaker, hunched forward in the prisoner's box.

After a roll call, the tall dark-haired jury foreman stood and, with the single word - "Guilty" - broke the electric silence.

  • Nancy Morrison inject potassium chloride into Mills's intravenous line a few minutes before he died;
  • Furthermore, even the suggestion of relief placebo has a significant analgesic effect;
  • Deputy Justice Minister Brent Cotter told the Globe and Mail, "What makes this different and exceptional is that it's alleged he was misconducting himself while performing his duties as a prosecutor.

Laura Latimer immediately burst from her seat behind the prisoner's box, slammed her hand against a railing, screaming: Twenty minutes later, they returned with their defiant recommendation: We had no options. I cannot understand these people.

  • It is well established that the common law should develop in accordance with Charter principles;
  • I'm more worried about my husband than the stupid farm;
  • It is a discretion, too, that must at all times be exercised with great caution, a caution that must be re-doubled as the seriousness of the matter increases.

I'm more worried about my husband than the stupid farm.